Markets / Economy
Builder Confidence Drops to Its Lowest Since April 2012 as Mortgage Rates Above 7% Sideline Buyers
Buyer traffic is at a 15-year low and nearly half of builders are cutting prices, pointing to a weak winter for new-home building.
Builder confidence fell four points to 25 in November, its lowest since April 2012, as high mortgage rates kept buyers on the sidelines.
The National Association of Home Builders released the November survey on Tuesday, November 17, 2026. It covers builders of newly built single-family homes.
The NAHB/Wells Fargo Housing Market Index (HMI), a monthly gauge of builder sentiment, fell to 25. Any reading below 50 means more builders see conditions as poor than good.
The survey has run for more than 40 years. Builders rate current sales, expected sales and buyer traffic as good, fair or poor.
Scores for each component feed the single headline reading. The index is seasonally adjusted.
November extends the slide TickerGrove reported in October. October's reading was 29, and the index now sits at its lowest since April 2012.
NAHB tied the drop to high mortgage rates and elevated energy and material costs. It also cited ongoing inflation pressure and hesitant buyers.
Every component fell in November
Current sales conditions fell six points to 28. Future sales expectations for the next six months fell two points to 30.
Prospective buyer traffic fell two points to 16. NAHB said traffic reached its lowest in 15 years, excluding the start of the pandemic.
Economists polled by Reuters had forecast the index unchanged at 29. The actual reading of 25 missed that forecast by four points, a TickerGrove calculation.
Regional scores fell everywhere on a three-month moving average. The Northeast dropped four points to 34, and the Midwest fell five points to 35.
The South fell three points to 27. The West fell three points to 23, the lowest regional score.
Price cuts and incentives hit post-Covid highs
In November, 46% of builders reduced prices. NAHB called that share the highest in the post-Covid period.
The average price reduction held at 6%. It stayed unchanged for an eighth straight month.
Sales incentives were used by 68% of builders, also a post-Covid high. November was the 20th straight month at least 60% of builders used them.
That mix is defensive. Nearly half of builders cut prices and more than two-thirds offered incentives, yet traffic still fell.
Labor, materials and rates squeeze builders
Chairman Bill Owens blamed stepped-up immigration enforcement for deepening labor shortages. He said it is keeping legal workers off job sites and driving up costs.
Owens said: “Stepped-up immigration enforcement is keeping legal workers off job sites, deepening labor shortages and driving up costs.”
He said higher fuel prices are prompting subcontractors to raise rates sharply. With fewer buyers in the market, more builders are scaling back construction.
Chief Economist Robert Dietz cited material costs pushed higher by tariffs. He also cited an ongoing worker shortage and excessive regulation.
Dietz said: “Mortgage rates above 7%, softer consumer confidence and an uncertain economic outlook are holding buyers back.”
Reuters reported the 30-year fixed mortgage rate has risen 120 basis points since February. A basis point is one hundredth of a percentage point.
Reuters tied that rise to the period since the United States and Israel attacked Iran in February.
The rate averaged 7.40% in mid-October, a three-year high in Freddie Mac data cited by Reuters. It has since eased to an average of 7.18%.
Sales of previously owned homes fell to their lowest in more than 16 years in October. Reuters attributed that reading to the National Association of Realtors.
An overhang of unsold new homes also constrains building, Reuters reported. Higher material prices from import tariffs add to the pressure.
The survey's message is two-sided. Demand is weak because rates keep buyers out, and supply is costly because labor and materials are dearer.
What remains unknown
Whether mortgage rates ease further from 7.18% is unknown. The November survey reports conditions, not where rates go next.
How long the labor shortage tied to enforcement will last is unanswered. NAHB describes the effect on job sites, not its duration.
Whether deeper price cuts will bring buyers back is unknown. Traffic fell to 16 even as 46% of builders cut prices.
What December demand looks like after the November cuts is also unknown. The survey predates any response to the latest reductions.
The tests that come next
What to watch: the December HMI reading, the next month in this survey series. A second month near 25 would confirm the slump's depth.
Mortgage rates are the second test. A sustained move below 7% would test whether buyers return at lower rates.
Traffic is the third test. A reading still near 16 would show that cuts and incentives are not yet drawing buyers in.
Incentives are the fourth test. A 21st straight month at or above 60% would show builders still leaning on them.
Sources & evidence
Source checked2 sources · 10 figures
Figure receipts
Sources
Sources used for this piece.
As of Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026.

Discuss this story. Join TickerGrove on Discord to talk companies, earnings, and markets, or request future coverage.

